So, even if there is that half a percent chance it DID actually exist, it still could not account for these supposed historical mentions of things like the wormwood star.
I think most supposed historical accounts of this 'object'….
Don't confuse "historical" with "mythological," wormwood being the latter.
The Hopi's with their 'Blue star katchina' were probably talking about the very rare event that dust & gasses in space can turn the moon blue.
The Hopi kachinas are completely and utterly warped by woo artists on the Internet. It's amusing how many cranks over the years have attributed multiple different objects to alleged kachina-related "prophecies." I encountered a weirdo on YouTube earlier this year convinced that the blue star kachina was Comet Elenin.
Also could it be possible that the solar system we know today is the solar system that is left as a result of this 'planet' passing through it millions of years ago?
Only if you throw out everything we know about orbital mechanics.
As for this Annunaki theory, I'm still out on it to be honest with you.
To be honest, there's no theory to be out on. There's just a bunch of nonsense claims by disciples of a wannabe archaeologist/historian, none of which have any demonstrable basis in reality.
I don't believe in nibiru as anything beyond our neighbor, jupiter, but the theory that beings from somewhere else in the universe did come here and lay the building blocks for a civilised race, similar to themselves. I have never been selfish enough to think humans are the only life out there because the odds of that being wrong are infinate. Galaxies that hold millions of stars, millions & billions of galaxies & stars, and each star we can't see gives the chance of there being planets in orbit around it, and planets give you the chance of life.
Even if all of that is true, the odds of any particular alien civilizations A) consisting concurrently with any given Earth civilizations and B) contacting/visiting Earth remain astronomically low, the stuff of science fiction and woo. And, of course, there's the complete lack of any evidence even remotely suggesting that such a thing ever happened.
On the other hand, as noted above by Elliott, we have tons of evidence that life evolved right here on Earth, starting as simple, self-replicating chemicals and developing into numerous species suited to numerous terrestrial environments, over billions of years.
Perhaps Nibiru does exist, a few hundred lightyears away somewhere in the milky way or another galaxy somewhere different completely.
So you're just piling your own fiction on top of Sitchin's. That's not good thinking.
This would explain the annunaki and discount the 'massive object' in our solar system.
The Annunaki already have an ample explanation, found in ancient Sumerian mythology. They no more need explaining beyond that than do Zeus, Thor and Pangu.